Hi Jennie,
I have a 15 week old baby boy named Joshua. He is my first. I would be happy to correspond. My e-mail should be shown above (?).
My first advice is to make sure you are seeing a specialist who knows the full treatment range of options. We didn't discover until Joshua was 8 weeks old that the orthopedic surgeon we were seeing "didn't believe in" primary surgery because he thought it was only done at TCH and he had a negative opinion of TCH. I informed him that primary was done at quite a number of places, including at least three in California, and was commonly accepted (the only debate seems to be in deciding who will benefit and when to do the surgery).
Besides having Douglas followed for possible treatment options later, you want to make sure he didn't actually have broken bones or dislocations that need to be addressed separately.
That said, I do think Joshua experienced a lot of pain around 2-4 weeks old. I think the muscle damage that can occur during such a traumatic birth is highly under estimated! If the neck area is stretched enough to tear nerves, it certainly is going to strain and possibly tear muscles as well.
In Joshua's case, the muscles in his neck that turned his head to the right were injured - his sternomastoid muscle on his BPI side was injured along with some muscles for turning his head in his back. His head was twisted during the birth enough to tear these muscles, resulting in a torticollis or "twisted neck". They were probably painful at first, then they scar up and heal, then around 2-4 weeks old the scar starts reabsorbing and the torn muscle pulls back together, which causes tightness and (in our case) real discomfort. At the same time, he really started fussing whenever we did his range of motion stretches, too. I think it was all related.
Our orthopedic surgeon specialist finally told us about the condition and recommended stretches for those muscles (at 5 weeks old).
Joshua HATED HATED HATED the neck stretchies and ROMS when we first did them, but the doctor was adamant that if we didn't he would be in even more pain and discomfort. So I put in earplugs and stretched him every three hours by the clock for four days straight - 8AM, 11AM, 2PM, 5PM and 8PM. During those first four days Joshua screamed whenever I went to pick him up, didn't want to be held, stopped gaining weight (because he didn't want to be that close to me to eat...
) and was REALLY REALLY unhappy. But, miracle of miracles... on the fourth day suddenly they didn't hurt anymore. Suddenly he stopped fighting the stretches and relaxed. Suddenly he started falling to sleep while I was doing them. The muscles loosened up, he got the range of motion back in his neck, and he wanted to be held again.
There may be olther real things causing Douglas discomfort that are also a result of the traumatic birth. The nerves can also give off weird and possibly uncomfortable signals as they heal. And as Douglas gets more and more use of the other arm, you may notice some baby "frustration" with the arm that doesn't work. After all, their brain EXPECTS that arm to work - it worked in utero, after all.
And don't underestimate your emotional state in all of this. For a long time, I couldn't nurse Joshua without crying on him... They pick up on that, as well. And the more unhappy he seemed, the more sad I got. It was a horrible circle. And when you absolutely MUST do painful or uncomfortable things to your prescious little boy on top of what has already happened to him... it is really hard and seems SO HORRIBLY UNFAIR. But it must be done. This is the ultimate "tough love".
My advice: Grit your teeth, get a good pair of earplugs and hang in there... it WILL get better. Once you get the muscles loosened up, it won't be so uncomfortable. Once Douglas learns that you aren't trying to hurt him and stops fighting it, it will get easier.
Kate